虎嗅

Behind the $50 billion in bad debts, why did consumer finance misjudge middle-aged adults in their 40s?

原文:500亿坏账背后,消费金融为何看错了40岁中年人?

Summary of Key Points

As of June this year, 24 consumer finance institutions across the country have accumulated bad debts amounting to 50 billion yuan, involving over ten million consumer loans. Surprisingly, the main group of defaulters is not the younger generation but rather middle-aged individuals born in the 1980s, with an average age of 40. These individuals have both elderly parents and children to support, and they are not deliberately avoiding repayments; they simply cannot afford to pay. This phenomenon highlights the debt burdens and economic difficulties faced by this demographic, serving as a warning for both the consumer finance industry and the overall economy.

Detailed Analysis

1. How significant is the amount of 50 billion yuan in bad debts? How many lifetimes would it take for an average person to save that much?

The figure of 50 billion yuan may seem abstract, but let’s put it into context:

  • Assuming an average family can save 5,000 yuan per month (which is already considered a good savings rate), it would take 833,000 families saving for one year or one family saving for 833,000 years to accumulate such a sum.
  • Comparing this with the national average disposable income of 39,200 yuan per person in 2023, 50 billion yuan is equivalent to the combined annual income of 1.275 million ordinary people.
  • Considering the scale of the consumer finance industry, 50 billion yuan in bad debts represents nearly one-third of the industry’s total annual profit (about 150 billion yuan in 2023), which is a significant loss for the institutions.

In other words, this is not a small amount; it’s a substantial financial hole that needs to be addressed.

2. Why are middle-aged individuals born in the 1980s the main group of defaulters? Their pressures come from three major challenges:

The average age of these individuals (40) coincides with a particularly challenging period in their lives:

  • First challenge: Mortgages and car loans: They were the primary buyers of homes during the 2000s-2010s, and many are still paying 30-year mortgages, with monthly payments accounting for 30%-50% of their income. Adding car loans, fixed expenses account for a large portion of their earnings.
  • Second challenge: Children’s education: With children in elementary to high school, costs for extracurricular classes, tutoring, and school district housing are substantial.
  • Third challenge: Caring for parents’ elderly care and medical expenses: Parents, typically around 60-70 years old, are more prone to health issues, and the out-of-pocket costs after insurance coverage can be considerable, sometimes reaching tens of thousands of yuan if they need hospitalization.

Moreover, the 1980s generation is facing a “midlife crisis” in the workplace, with layoffs being common in industries such as technology, real estate, and education, leading to reduced income or unemployment, which further strains their already tight budgets.

3. “It’s not that they don’t want to pay; they can’t afford to”—How difficult is it for middle-aged individuals to manage their finances?

This statement hits a common issue: The 1980s generation is not deliberately defaulting; they truly lack the means to repay their debts. For example, a typical family with a monthly income of 20,000 yuan might face the following expenses:

  • Mortgage: 8,000 yuan
  • Children’s education: 3,000 yuan
  • Parents’ medical care: 2,000 yuan
  • Daily expenses: 3,000 yuan
  • Only 4,000 yuan remains each month.

If their income drops (e.g., to 15,000 yuan), they might have to rely on consumer loans to make ends meet. Without a source of income after losing their job, they would be unable to repay their mortgage and other loans, leading to default.

Their expenses are fixed (such as mortgages and education costs), while their income is variable (due to potential salary cuts or unemployment), creating an imbalance that leads to financial collapse.

4. What impact does the increase in bad debts have on us as ordinary people?

This issue is not just limited to consumer finance institutions; it affects everyone indirectly:

  • More difficult access to loans: Institutions, wary of bad debts, will tighten lending policies (e.g., raising credit requirements, reducing loan amounts, and increasing interest rates), making it harder to obtain consumer loans for activities like buying phones or traveling.
  • More cautious spending: With fewer middle-aged consumers, businesses in related industries (such as dining and retail) may see a decline in sales, which could lead to job losses.
  • Possible policy changes: The government might introduce measures to help alleviate the burden on this group, such as supporting employment (preventing layoffs), lowering mortgage rates, or increasing medical insurance reimbursement, which would benefit us all.

5. What warning does this situation pose for the economy?

The 50 billion yuan in bad debts is not an isolated incident; it reflects two critical issues:

  • Excessive debt burdens on residents: The debt levels of middle-aged individuals have reached a critical point, and widespread defaults could trigger a chain reaction, such as increased bank bad debts and reduced consumer spending.
  • Economic recovery depends on addressing people’s needs: To revive the economy, we need to ensure that residents feel confident enough to spend and are able to repay their debts. This requires addressing their immediate concerns, such as stabilizing employment, reducing the cost of education and healthcare, and regulating the consumer loan market.

For everyone, this is a reminder to be cautious when taking out consumer loans, especially middle-aged individuals, and to maintain an emergency fund to avoid letting debt overwhelm their lives.

In conclusion

The default difficulties faced by middle-aged individuals born in the 1980s are not just personal problems but result from the combined effects of the times and the economic environment. Solving this issue requires the joint efforts of institutions, the government, and individuals—financial institutions should avoid reckless lending, the government should provide support to reduce burdens, and individuals should consume wisely to ensure that everyone can afford their debts.