第一财经

"Intelligent Economic Governance Systems Urgently Need Systematic Innovation"

原文:智能经济治理体系亟待系统性革新

Summary of Key Points

The intelligent economy has become a core strategy for promoting high-quality development in our country. It represents an upgrade of the digital economy, empowered by artificial intelligence (AI). Its core characteristics include a reconfiguration of production factors (with high-quality data playing a central role), production tools (emphasizing the collaboration of humans and intelligence), and the emergence of a new type of workforce (composed of highly skilled, intelligent professionals). This transformation brings about profound changes in industrial organization, profit distribution, and social governance. However, it also exposes challenges such as misconceptions in governance concepts, inadequate institutional adaptations, outdated tools, and a lack of legal frameworks. To ensure the healthy development of the intelligent economy, it is necessary to establish a modern governance system that addresses these aspects.

I. What Makes the Intelligent Economy Truly “New”? Three Key Changes to Understand

The most significant difference between the intelligent economy and previous economic models (agriculture, industry, digital economy) lies in the complete reconfiguration of the three key elements of productivity:

1. **Data from “Information” to “Money Maker”: In the past, production relied on land, labor, and capital; the digital economy uses data. However, the intelligent economy requires higher-quality data—such as precise user behavior and factory equipment operation data. This data, when processed by algorithms and computing power, can be integrated into all stages of production, sales, and consumption. For example, e-commerce uses data to recommend products, increasing sales, and factories use it to optimize production lines, reducing waste. This breaks the old pattern of “the more you work, the slower you earn” and continuously improves efficiency.

2. **Production Tools as “Intelligent Partners”: Traditional methods involved assembly lines and machines; now, intelligent robots, large models, and industrial intelligents are used. The production model has shifted from standardized mass production to customized production on demand. For instance, you can order a garment online, and an intelligent factory can quickly adjust its production process. This collaboration between humans and machines enhances efficiency and accuracy.

3. Workers Must Be Proficient with Intelligence: In the past, workers simply needed to operate machines; now, they must understand digital technologies and use intelligent tools. New professions such as data analysts, algorithm engineers, and intelligent maintenance specialists have emerged, while jobs that require brute force or basic operations are becoming increasingly rare.

II. The Changes and Concerns Brought by the Intelligent Economy: Impact on Industry, Distribution, and Governance

The intelligent economy not only changes how products are made but also reshapes the way society operates, introducing new issues:

1. Industrial Organization Becomes “Networked,” but Regulation is Challenging: Enterprises no longer follow a hierarchical structure (bosses manage middle managers, who manage employees); instead, there is a networked collaboration. Small businesses can collaborate with multiple platforms, and “one-person companies” (operating with AI tools) or “platform ecosystems” (like creators on TikTok) are becoming more common. However, this leads to difficulties in regulation, as it’s unclear who is responsible for what within the supply chain, and traditional industry regulations no longer apply.

2. Profit Distribution Becomes More Diverse, but Inequalities Widen: Profit distribution no longer solely relies on labor or capital; data, algorithms, and computing power also generate revenue. For example, platforms earn from advertising based on user data, and tech companies sell services using algorithms. However, ordinary workers may be replaced by AI, leading to reduced incomes. Income disparities between industries (e.g., between the AI and traditional sectors) and the digital divide (those who cannot use intelligent tools are left behind) are becoming more pronounced, and existing systems for income distribution and social security are inadequate.

3. Social Governance Becomes More Complex, but Risks Increase: Governance now involves multiple stakeholders, including governments, platforms, and social organizations, extending from physical spaces (e.g., street patrols) to digital realms (e.g., AI-related fraud and virtual world issues). Risks are more concealed, such as data breaches (personal information being sold) and algorithmic discrimination (AI rejecting loans based on location). Traditional post-event response mechanisms are insufficient to address these challenges.

III. Current Barriers to the Development of the Intelligent Economy: Four Key Issues to Overcome

Although the intelligent economy is growing rapidly, the supporting systems and governance mechanisms are not keeping up:

1. Misconceptions in Governance Concepts: Some regions apply outdated regulations to the intelligent economy, restricting innovation, while others allow unchecked chaos, leading to problems like the spread of false information.

2. Inadequate Institutional Rules: There are no clear rules for managing data as a core asset—how to define ownership, trade it, and set prices? Similarly, there are no clear regulations for algorithms and computing power, causing confusion in market entry and competition.

3. Outdated Governance Tools: Traditional methods (manual inspections and post-event accountability) are insufficient for the real-time, cross-sectoral operations of the intelligent economy. Lack of intelligent monitoring and early warning systems, as well as inadequate coordination between departments, hinders governance efficiency.

4. Lack of Legal Protections: Existing laws are primarily designed for the traditional economy. For example, there are no clear regulations regarding liability in case of AI-related issues or how to penalize algorithmic discrimination. This creates uncertainty for innovative companies and provides loopholes for offenders.

IV. How to Ensure the Stable Development of the Intelligent Economy: Building a Modern Governance System

To overcome these challenges, a comprehensive upgrade in both concepts and systems is needed:

1. Inclusive and Principled Governance: Allow for experimentation with new technologies and business models, setting boundaries for tolerance (as long as safety is not compromised). In areas like data security and algorithm ethics, establish clear standards (e.g., no data breaches). Shift from passive regulation to proactive support, and from static rules to dynamic adjustments.

2. Improving Rules for New Elements: Quickly establish regulations for data ownership, trading, and profit distribution to facilitate data flow between platforms. Improve systems for algorithm registration and computing power management to protect intellectual property. Simplify the entry process for new intelligent businesses and provide support policies (e.g., subsidies for traditional companies to upgrade their technology).

3. Using Technology for Governance: Utilize big data, AI, and blockchain to build monitoring and early warning systems for risks (e.g., false information generated by AI) and to take precise actions (e.g., promptly banning违规 accounts). Establish cross-departmental coordination.

4. Balancing Innovation and Risk Prevention: Enact laws that clarify the boundaries of innovation (e.g., protecting AI developers’ rights) and define penalties for violations. Improve labor and income distribution laws to address the needs of workers affected by AI, narrowing the digital divide.

By implementing these measures, the intelligent economy can innovate while maintaining safety, truly becoming a driving force for high-quality development.