Summary of Key Points
Recently, the Japanese yen has experienced a rapid appreciation that occurs only once in several decades, with the largest single-day increase exceeding 3%, effectively reversing the depreciation trend that had persisted for three years. This market movement is not the result of natural market fluctuations; it is essentially a power struggle between the United States and Japan. The U.S. is facing pressure on its own debt market and fears that Japan will continue to sell its massive holdings of U.S. bonds, which could destabilize its financial system. As a result, the U.S. has forced Japan to abandon its ultra-low interest rate policy, which has been in place for nearly 30 years, and to start raising interest rates. Japan, on the other hand, has been using near-zero interest rates to reduce the burden on businesses and consumers in an attempt to revive its economy, which has been sluggish for three decades. Now, under U.S. pressure to raise interest rates, Japan is essentially being forced to sacrifice its own economic stability to support the U.S. The two countries are in a very awkward and tense standoff.
---
Detailed Analysis
1. The immediate impacts of the yen's appreciation on ordinary people
Many have noticed this change. A few years ago, 1 yuan could exchange for 21 yen, meaning a 1000-yen cosmetic product could be purchased for 50 yuan. Now, with the yen appreciating, 1 yuan can only exchange for 17 or 18 yen, so the same product has become nearly 60 yuan more expensive. People planning to travel to Japan will find that round-trip airfare and hotel prices have increased by several hundred to even thousands of yuan overnight. Families with children studying in Japan will need to spend an additional ten to twenty thousand yuan on tuition and living expenses each year. Those who do business importing goods from Japan are also hesitant to stock up, fearing that the rising exchange rate will result in insufficient profits to cover the cost of converting money. These are the direct consequences of the yen's sharp appreciation, which significantly affects many people's wallets.
2. Why can Japan's holdings of U.S. bonds pose a threat to the U.S.?
In essence, the U.S. is currently a country that relies on borrowing to fund its operations, with most of its daily expenses, military spending, and welfare payments coming from issuing government bonds (i.e., taking out loans from the world). Japan has been the U.S.'s largest creditor for over a decade, holding more than $1.3 trillion in U.S. bonds, which is equivalent to holding over $1 trillion in U.S. IOUs. When the U.S. suddenly raised interest rates, the market value of these bonds dropped by more than 20%. Fearing significant losses, Japan began to sell these bonds aggressively. If Japan continues to sell its bonds, no one will be willing to buy new U.S. bonds, forcing the U.S. to offer even higher interest rates in the future. This could lead to doubling of mortgage payments for American households, increased borrowing costs for businesses, and the U.S. government struggling to even cover the interest on its debts. Japan could potentially burst the U.S. financial bubble if it continues to sell its bonds, a consequence that the U.S. cannot afford.
3. Why has Japan hesitated to raise interest rates for decades?
Many may wonder why Japan would prefer to let the yen depreciate rather than raise interest rates. The reason is simple: Japan's total debt is 2.6 times its annual GDP, meaning the country owes 260,000 yuan for every 100,000 yuan it earns. With near-zero interest rates on bank deposits and loan rates below 1%, the Japanese government's annual debt payments are negligible, and businesses can borrow money to start or expand with almost no cost. Homebuyers pay just over 2,000 yuan in mortgage payments per month. If interest rates were raised to 3%, the government would have to spend half of its annual revenue on interest payments, leading to bankruptcy. Additionally, mortgage payments for households would triple, and many businesses would go bankrupt. Japan's economy has been sluggish for 30 years, and any signs of recovery in income and consumption would be destroyed by raising interest rates. Therefore, Japan has preferred to let the yen depreciate rather than risk raising interest rates.
4. The U.S. is pushing Japan to raise interest rates, effectively using Japan as a scapegoat
Raising interest rates would stop Japan from selling its bonds. The logic is straightforward: previously, low interest rates in Japan made it attractive for people to convert their money into U.S. bonds for higher returns. If Japan raises interest rates and offers 3% on bank deposits, it would be more profitable to keep money in Japanese banks than to buy U.S. bonds. Businesses, households, and institutions would then sell their U.S. bonds and deposit the yen in Japanese banks for higher returns. Moreover, the appreciation of the yen would lead to a depreciation of the dollar, making U.S. cars and electronics cheaper for export, potentially increasing U.S. exports and shifting inflationary pressures to Japan. Thus, the U.S. benefits significantly from forcing Japan to raise interest rates, while Japan faces severe consequences: a surge in domestic debt, a slowdown in its economy, with the U.S. showing no concern for Japan's well-being.
5. What will happen in this standoff between the U.S. and Japan, and what does it mean for us?
Japan is not foolish and will not raise interest rates significantly at the U.S.'s request. It is likely to adopt a symbolic increase, such as raising rates from 0 to 0.5% and allowing the yen to appreciate by about 10%, while temporarily stopping the sale of U.S. bonds to appease the U.S. However, Japan will not raise rates too much to avoid economic collapse. This standoff will continue for several months. For ordinary people, the impact will be tangible: travel and the cost of Japanese goods will remain high for the next six months, but companies exporting to Japan will benefit from cheaper prices for their products. Additionally, as the U.S. reduces the pressure on U.S. bond sales, China's monetary policy will not be so constrained by the U.S., allowing for more flexibility in interest rate cuts and support for the real economy, which is good news for consumers.