虎嗅

"731 Groups of CP: Behind the Absurdity of Children, There's a Complete Lack of Experiential Education"

原文:拿731组CP:孩子的荒谬背后,是体验教育的全面缺失

Summary of the News Analysis

This article highlights a hidden issue in the domestic business and technology community: many internet finance and news platforms targeting young users are distorting the true history of the domestic internet industry’s development. Under the guise of “revealing industry secrets” and “exposing the truth about industry leaders,” these platforms use a form of historical nihilism to misrepresent the facts, misleading young professionals and students who have not experienced the early stages of the industry. By creating opposition and spreading conspiracy theories, they not only distort young people’s understanding of business innovation but also harm the overall innovative atmosphere of the industry.

Detailed Analysis

Why Does Historical Nihilism Occur in the Business and Technology Field?

Historical nihilism, which previously involved manipulating revolutionary history and defaming heroes, has now shifted its focus to the internet industry. When you watch short videos or read content from various business accounts, you might come across claims that Jack Ma’s success was backed by mysterious investors, that WeChat’s inception was a copy of foreign products, or that Alibaba’s success in e-commerce was due to tolerating the sale of counterfeit goods. These claims ignore the reality that when the domestic internet was just starting out, entrepreneurs had to educate people about online shopping and policy makers had to carefully trial and error to create a space for the new economy. Instead, these stories are filled with unproven conspiracy theories and negative rumors, turning the real history of the industry into a melodramatic version of power struggles.

Why Does This Misleading Trend Target the Young?

The reason is simple: young people today either have just entered the internet industry or are still in school and have no experience with the PC internet era before 2010. They are not familiar with basic industry concepts, making them susceptible to misleading “secrets” that are often fabricated. Additionally, young people tend to be skeptical of “heroes” and such stories that suggest success through unethical means tap into their desire to see authorities fail, leading to rapid spread of these false narratives. As a result, these platforms gain traffic, while young people are led to believe that hard work is useless and that shortcuts and connections are more important, which hinders their career development.

The Consequences of Allowing This Misinformation to Spread Are More Serious Than Just Entertainment

This misinformation affects the entire next generation of innovators. If young people believe that all internet companies’ success is based on deception or copying, who will be motivated to invest in core technology? Instead, they may focus on creating stories and making quick money. A few years ago, self-media outlets claimed that all domestic AI models were based on foreign ones, discouraging computer science graduates from working in domestic AI companies. Serious companies that have invested in technology for over a decade have had their efforts dismissed by such baseless claims, to the detriment of the entire industry.

How Can Ordinary Young People Avoid This Cognitive Corruption?

The barriers to avoiding this misinformation are low. When you come across content claiming to expose the “dark side of internet leaders” or “unknown industry rules,” ask yourself two questions:

1. Are there any official timelines, reports, or accounts from industry insiders to support the claims? Or are they just baseless rumors from someone who works at a big company? If there is no evidence, ignore them.

2. What is the purpose of the content? Does it provide useful information about the challenges entrepreneurs faced or does it merely spread negative conclusions? The latter serves to reinforce cynicism without any real benefit.

The real history of business development is not perfect; it includes mistakes and failures, but it is certainly not built on conspiracy. By reading honest memoirs from industry insiders, you can avoid being misled by these fabricated stories.