Hello! I'm your financial analysis assistant. This article about "Grandpa Doesn't Make Tea" is not just about a milk tea brand; it's more of a microcosm of the new tea drink industry transitioning from rapid, unregulated growth to more refined and targeted operations.
To help you understand it easily, I'll first summarize the key points in plain language and then break down the intricacies from five different perspectives.
📝 Summary of Key Points
In one sentence:
Grandpa Doesn't Make Tea has established itself in Wuhan with its unique Hubei flavors, such as Xiaogan rice wine and Enshi Yulu tea. It tried to expand rapidly across the country through franchising, but due to limitations in funding, a fragmented supply chain, and increased competition, it didn't achieve the same scale benefits as brands like Mishi Ice City. Now, it has to shift from reckless expansion to more meticulous management, focusing on strengthening its presence in its home market and carefully entering other provinces, emphasizing the brand's regional roots as a way to survive.
---
🔍 In-Depth Analysis: Understanding Grandpa Doesn't Make Tea's Successes and Challenges
1. How to Build a Competitive Advantage: By Leveraging Regional Ingredients
Plain Language: People used to think of milk tea as just sugar water mixed with tea, but that's no longer the case. The clever strategy of Grandpa Doesn't Make Tea is that it doesn't position itself as just another chain milk tea shop; instead, it presents itself as a "carrier of Hubei's specialties."
- Specific Approach: Instead of buying ingredients randomly, the brand uses only the best from Hubei. For example, its signature "Litchi Ice Wine" is made with rice wine from Xiaogan, fresh lime juice, and Chaoshan single-cone tea. Other products like Enshi Yulu, Chibi green brick tea, and Xianning osmanthus tea create a sense of authenticity in consumers' minds.
- Why It Works: In a market full of Yangzhi Ganlu and pearl milk tea, claiming to have a "Hubei flavor" creates a distinctiveness. It's like opening a restaurant that specializes in Wuhan hot dry noodles; although niche, it becomes memorable once customers try it. This is what the article calls having a "regional identity"—once you occupy a place with a unique flavor, others can't easily copy it.
2. Why the Slow Start: Quality Over Quantity
Plain Language: Many might wonder why Grandpa Doesn't Make Tea has only over 2,000 stores compared to Mishi Ice City's tens of thousands. The reason is their different approaches.
- Early Strategy: From 2018 to 2022, the brand focused on direct operations, keeping the number of stores below 20. During this time, they tested which Hubei ingredients were truly delicious and which were just gimmicks (such as lotus root starch and round dumplings, which didn't appeal to customers).
- Contrast: Mishi Ice City expanded rapidly during this period, benefiting from scale. Grandpa Didn't Make Tea focused on refining its products and building a strong brand image, avoiding reckless expansion. This is like two students: one rushes through practice problems to increase scores quickly, while the other delves into difficult ones for better long-term results.
- Cost: This slow approach came at a cost. When the industry took off, Grandpa Didn't Make Tea missed out on the biggest scale benefits due to its smaller footprint.
3. Expansion Challenges: High Hopes, Low Reality
Plain Language: After opening up franchising in 2022, Grandpa Didn't Make Tea aimed to open 5,000 stores by 2025, but reality was harsh.
- Reality: As of August this year, it only has 2,781 stores, far from its goal. Why?
1. Lack of Funds and Resources: Without significant funding, expansion relied on its own capital, making it difficult to expand quickly.
2. Changing Industry Landscape: The market has shifted from one of new entrants to one where businesses compete for existing customers. Even Mishi Ice City's profits are declining, indicating the end of the era of profit growth through sheer quantity.
- Distribution Issues: Grandpa Doesn't Make Tea's stores are spread out, mainly in Hubei, Zhejiang, and Guangdong, with low concentration (9.13%). In contrast, brands like Gu Ming have high concentration in key provinces.
- Example: It's like scattering pepper all over the country; each store gets a small amount, making logistics costly. Competitors with dense stores in certain areas can deliver to many stores at lower costs.
4. The Supply Chain as a Weakness
Plain Language: In the food industry, products are the face, but the supply chain is the foundation. Grandpa Doesn't Make Tea's challenge is that its unique ingredients are also its burden.
- Costs: Hubei specialties like rice wine and tea have limited national supply chains, leading to higher procurement costs and more complex logistics.
- Distribution Challenges: Despite having 24 warehouses and achieving T+2 delivery, the scattered stores prevent efficient distribution.
- Consequences: In a price-war environment, higher costs make it hard to compete. Without significant brand recognition, it can't rely on price discounts, and higher costs prevent further expansion.
5. From Expansion to Precision: The New Approach
Plain Language: Since rapid expansion isn't working, the brand has adopted a more pragmatic strategy.
- Strengthening the Home Market: It's focusing on expanding in Hubei and increasing store density to reduce logistics costs and reinforce the brand's local identity.
- Targeted Expansion: It's choosing key provinces like Guangdong and Zhejiang for localized marketing, adapting its products to local tastes (e.g., introducing "White Peach Yellow Peel Ice" and using local folk symbols like pomelo leaves).
- Industry Lesson: This article warns small and medium-sized brands not to pursue nationwide expansion without a strong supply chain and funding. Instead, they should build a strong brand in a specific region and focus on operational efficiency.
💡 Lessons for Everyone
1. Consumer Choice: Try the regional products at Grandpa Doesn't Make Tea; they offer a unique and memorable experience.
2. Business Logic: For entrepreneurs and investors, small, distinctive brands are more sustainable than large, generic ones. In a competitive market, efficiency and differentiation are more important than scale.
3. Industry Trends: The new tea drink industry is no longer about easy profits. Success will come to those who can minimize supply chain costs and tell a unique brand story. Grandpa Doesn't Make Tea is struggling to find this balance, and its performance will be a valuable case study for the future of the industry.