India Asks to Be the “6G Leader”: Can the “Pie” Really Be Divided Equally?
Hello everyone, I’m your financial journalist. Recently, there’s been a quite lively topic in the tech world: India has once again declared its ambition to become a global leader in the 6G era.
Such a declaration is certainly inspiring, considering India’s large population and vast market, as well as the rapid growth in 5G users. However, as financial analysts, we can’t just rely on slogans; we need to look at a country’s underlying capabilities and strength. Today, I’ll break down this news in simple terms to help you understand whether India’s 6G ambitions are based on solid foundations or are just empty promises.
I. Summary of the Main Points: Ambitious Goals, but Weak Foundations
In short, this article states that the Indian government and companies are making significant efforts to prepare for 6G, from issuing documents and allocating frequency bands to forming alliances and investing funds, with the goal of commercialization by 2030 and securing 10% of the world’s patents.
However, the article also points out some challenges: despite having a large number of 5G users and good relations with Europe and the US, India still lags far behind leaders like China, Europe, and the US in terms of the number of base stations, core patents, chip manufacturing capabilities, and actual research and development (R&D) investment.
In one sentence: India wants to use 6G to catch up or even overtake others, but its technology and infrastructure are not yet ready, and it’s mainly relying on market size and diplomatic influence to gain a voice in the global arena.
---
II. In-Depth Analysis: Five Dimensions to Understand India’s 6G Ambitions
To make it clearer, I’ve broken down the information from the news into five aspects:
1. Timeline Comparison: Is India Rushing or Planning Cautiously?
There’s an interesting detail in the news: India started 5G commercialization three years later than China (October 2022 vs late 2019). Normally, a country that falls behind would focus on catching up first, but India moved quickly, releasing a 6G vision document less than half a year after 5G was launched.
- India’s Timeline: 5G launched in 2022; basic research and alliance building from 2023-2025; testing and chip development from 2025-2030, with commercialization targeted for 2030.
- China’s Timeline: Released a 6G white paper in 2021 (one and a half years after 5G commercialization), taking a more cautious and focused approach on technology development.
Interpretation: India’s eagerness to talk about 6G before fully mastering 5G is like a student boasting about calculus skills before even learning addition. While it shows ambition, it also reveals anxiety about falling behind. They want to make up for the delay in 5G by taking a early lead in 6G.
2. What Does India Have Going for It?
India does have some substantial advantages that give it confidence:
- Large User Base: India is the second-largest 5G market in the world, with nearly 550 million users and expected to exceed 1 billion by 2030. In the communications industry, users equal market power, which gives operators the motivation to adopt new technologies and attracts international attention.
- Geopolitical Advantages: India has signed memorandums with the EU and partnered with companies like T-Mobile in the US, aiming to increase its voting rights in 6G standard setting. In other words, it’s trying to prevent China from dominating the rules.
- Allocated Frequency Bands: India has allocated the U6G band (around 6GHz) for mobile communications, a crucial frequency for 5G upgrades and 6G development. This early move has reserved a spot for future 6G networks.
Interpretation: India’s strengths lie in its soft power—a large market, flexible diplomacy, and quick policy responses. It hopes to use these to gain a role in 6G standard setting and market applications.
3. Critical Weaknesses: Why Experts Say It’s Difficult to Become a Leader?
The real challenges are evident:
- Significant Gap in Base Stations: India has only 523,000 5G base stations, compared to China’s 4.91 million—less than one-tenth of China’s. Fewer base stations mean lower network coverage and weaker capacity. This can lead to poor performance when more people use the network.
- Technological Dependence: India relies heavily on foreign companies like Ericsson, Nokia, and Samsung for 5G equipment and core components. Its so-called “local development” is limited to software integration, with core chips and components still imported.
- Patent Deficit: China, South Korea, the US, Japan, Sweden, and Finland hold 95.3% of global 5G patents, with India not even in the top 100. 6G is an upgrade of 5G, and without control over core technologies, leading in 6G is impossible.
- Limited R&D Investment: India has invested only 2.71 billion rupees (about 193 million yuan) in 104 6G projects, compared to billions of dollars invested by the EU and Japan. Additionally, India’s R&D spending as a percentage of GDP has long been below 1%. 6G requires substantial investment for breakthroughs.
Interpretation: India’s efforts seem like trying to host a large concert with a large audience and a rented venue, but with insufficient sound equipment and limited budget. It’s very challenging to aim for global leadership under these circumstances.
4. The Battle for Frequency Bands: The Strategic Importance of U6G
The news highlights the U6G band (6425–7125MHz):
- Understanding the Frequency Bands: Low-frequency bands (like 700MHz) provide wide coverage but slow speeds, while high-frequency bands (like millimeter waves) offer high speeds but limited coverage. The 6GHz band is a balance between the two, ideal for both 5G and 6G.
- India’s Actions: India has allocated this band for mobile communications and supports global standardization.
- China’s Actions: China’s Ministry of Industry and Information Technology has also approved 6G trials in this band.
Interpretation: Both India and China are moving in the same direction, following international trends and using open frequency bands to attract investment from companies like Ericsson and Nokia.
5. Final Positioning: What Role Can India Play?
Overall, it’s unrealistic for India to become the global leader in 6G technology. However, it can play a significant role as a key standard setter and a major market player:
- Reasons: India can’t compete head-to-head with China, the US, and Europe in terms of chips, base stations, and patents.
- Its Market Power: With over 1 billion potential users, any 6G company or operator looking to profit must consider the Indian market.
- Strategic Positioning: India will strive for favorable terms in standard negotiations and use its geopolitical influence to balance the power of China, the US, and Europe.
Conclusion: India won’t be the originator of 6G technology but can become an important player and influencer in the rules. It’s more likely to follow the lead while using its market power to secure its interests.
---
III. Lessons for Everyone
1. Don’t Be Misled by Slogans: When you see news about a country aiming to be a technology leader, check its patent portfolio, R&D investment, and infrastructure. Slogans are important, but technology speaks for itself.
2. 6G Is Still a Long Way Away: 6G is still in the research and standard-setting phase, with commercialization expected around 2030. Current discussions about leadership are more about politics and diplomacy than technical reality.
3. Pay Attention to the Supply Chain: For investors and industry players, India’s 6G plans mean opportunities in the overseas market. Although India’s technology is weak, it needs a lot of equipment, chips, and software services. Chinese companies have advantages in these areas and may enter the Indian market through exports or cooperation.
In summary: India’s 6G ambitions are ambitious, but its financial resources and technological capabilities are limited. It can gain a share of the 6G market, but becoming a leader will require significant improvements.