A Major Shift in the Real Estate Industry? An Easy-to-Understand Explanation of the Logic and Impacts Behind “Off-the-Market Housing Sales”
Hello everyone, I’m your financial journalist. The hottest topic in the real estate world these days is not about price cuts or market rescues, but rather off-the-market housing sales.
On September 18th, the Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development officially stated, “Off-the-market housing sales are an inevitable trend.” This means that when we buy a house, we might finally be moving away from buying something that’s not even built yet (pre-sale properties) and towards buying something that’s actually available for purchase.
To make this easier to understand, I’ve broken down this news into five key points and explained them in plain language: What exactly is happening? Why is this change taking place? What are the benefits for homebuyers? What impact will it have on developers? And what will the future of the real estate market look like?
---
Point 1: A Complete Shift from Promises to Reality
In one sentence: The government is changing the fundamental operating system of the real estate industry. In the past, developers acquired land, drew blueprints, collected payments for pre-sales, and then built the houses. In the future, developers will have to fund the construction themselves, ensure the houses meet quality standards, obtain the property certificates, and then sell them to buyers.
Key Actions:
1. Policy Direction: On August 28th, multiple ministries introduced new regulations, and on September 18th, the Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development reiterated that the “project company system, principal bank system, and off-the-market housing sales system” will be the three pillars of future real estate development.
2. Core Change: The focus has shifted from pre-sales to off-the-market housing as the preferred sales method. Although this won’t happen overnight, new projects will have to prioritize off-the-market sales, and the requirements for pre-sales have been significantly tightened.
3. Market Response: The land market has started to calm down, and developers are more cautious when acquiring land. Some cities, such as Lishui and Xiamen, have already mandated off-the-market housing sales for new developments.
---
Point 2: Why the Change? (The Challenges and Motivations)
Many people wonder: Didn’t pre-sales work well before? Developers could get their money back, and buyers could get houses at lower prices. Why change now?
1. Solving the Problems of Unfinished Buildings and Mismatched Products:
In the past, when buying a pre-sale property, you paid before the house was even built, relying entirely on trust. What happened? Some developers ran out of funds, leaving buildings unfinished; others built houses that didn’t match the promotional images, with reduced quality.
The core logic of off-the-market housing sales is: “You get what you see.” The house is built first, and you can inspect it, touch it, and test it before making a purchase. This fundamentally eliminates the risk of paying for something that never materializes.
2. Weeding Out Low-Quality Products and Improving Living Standards:
Expert Li Yujia points out that during the pre-sale era, developers often replicated the same designs across the country to speed up the process, leading to homogenized housing. The competition focused on price rather than quality. Off-the-market housing sales raise the bar, and only those developers who focus on quality and efficiency will survive. This is good news for homebuyers looking for better living conditions.
3. Restoring Market Confidence:
People are hesitant to buy houses because they fear not being able to purchase one or ending up with an unfinished building. Implementing off-the-market housing sales gives buyers more confidence, turning home buying into a more secure investment rather than a gamble.
---
Point 3: How Will the Three Systems Be Implemented? (The Specific Measures)
This reform is not just about changing the sales method; it involves regulating the entire process from development to financing to sales.
1. Project Company System: Each project will have its own independent financial account.
- Previously: Developers might use funds from Project A to support Project B or to pay off debts, leaving Project A without the necessary funds for construction.
- Now: Each project will have its own company, and its funds can only be used for that project, with strict regulations against misappropriation by the headquarters.
- This is like creating a firewall for each property, ensuring that funds are used for their intended purpose.
2. Principal Bank System: A designated bank (or bank consortium) will manage all the project’s finances.
- Previously: Financial supervision was often superficial or spread across multiple accounts, making it difficult to monitor.
- Now: Each project will have a principal bank that provides financing and services, acting as the “manager” and “gatekeeper” of the project’s finances.
3. Off-the-Market Housing Sales: New projects must prioritize off-the-market sales. If pre-sales are necessary (e.g., for large projects with long construction periods), strict financial oversight is required to ensure the funds are used for construction.
---
Point 4: What Does This Mean for Developers? (A Critical Test)
For developers, this is a critical test of their financial management skills.
1. Huge Financial Pressure and Increased Costs:
- Previously: Developers could start selling pre-sale properties just a few months after acquiring land, quickly recouping funds and starting construction.
- Now: They must fund the construction and completion of the house before selling it, extending the capital turnover period to more than two years.
- Financial Impact: According to ProRui Real Estate’s research, the additional costs (such as interest) under the off-the-market housing model amount to about 11% of the land price. This means that the extra expenses alone can exceed 10% of the land cost, posing a significant blow to already thin profits.
2. Changed Land Acquisition Strategies:
- Focus on Core Cities: Developers will concentrate on prime locations in major and secondary cities, where houses sell well and generate faster cash flows to cover these higher costs.
- Preference for Low-Density Properties: Houses like villas and multi-story homes, which require shorter construction times, will be more popular because longer construction periods increase financial pressure.
- Joint Land Acquisitions: Individual developers will be more cautious, and joint acquisitions by multiple companies will become common to share risks and costs.
- Lower Land Prices: Developers are less willing to bid high due to higher financial costs and longer construction periods, leading to more rational land transactions with lower premiums.
3. Accelerated Industry Consolidation:
Small and medium-sized developers that rely on high leverage and rapid turnover may struggle under the new requirements and exit the market. The industry will become more concentrated, with larger companies gaining a competitive advantage due to their financial strength.
---
Point 4: The Impact on Homebuyers and the Market (Benefits and Gradual Changes)
1. For Homebuyers: Greater peace of mind, as there’s no risk of unfinished buildings or mismatched products. You can inspect the house before buying, ensuring its quality, lighting, and neighborhood conditions.
- Price Impact: Although off-the-market housing sales increase developers’ costs, these may be passed on to buyers to some extent. However, with declining land prices and increased competition, overall housing prices are likely to remain stable or fluctuate slightly. The key benefit is that you’re buying a confirmed property with better value for money.
2. Market Transition: The change will be gradual, not immediate. Only a few cities (like Lishui, Xiamen, and Quanzhou) have mandated off-the-market housing sales, and these are mostly pilot programs.
- Trend: Most cities are still refining their policies, and off-the-market sales will not be mandatory for all projects. The focus will be on new projects first, with gradual implementation for existing ones.
- Land Market Response: New policies have led to lower land premiums. Developers are more cautious, indicating a return to a more rational market.
3. Long-Term Outlook: Real estate will move away from its financial focus and return to its core purpose of providing housing. Competition will shift from who can expand fastest to who can build the best quality products and provide the best services.
- For Ordinary People: This means better-quality houses, more reliable deliveries, and an improved living experience.
---
Journalist’s Comment and Summary
Off-the-market housing sales are not just a change in sales methods; they represent a fundamental restructuring of the real estate industry’s underlying logic.
- For the Government: It’s a crucial step in preventing systemic financial risks, protecting people’s livelihoods, and stabilizing public expectations.
- For Developers: It’s a catalyst for eliminating outdated practices and driving industry upgrading.
- For Homebuyers: It’s a safeguard for their rights and interests.
Advice for the Public:
1. Monitor Policy Updates: Pay attention to the latest land auction announcements in your city to see if off-the-market housing sales are mentioned.
2. Choose Off-the-Market or Nearly-Off-the-Market Properties: If available, these offer the lowest risk.
3. Rationally Evaluate Prices: Don’t rush into pre-sales due to concerns about higher prices. With off-the-market housing becoming the norm, the premium on pre-sales will likely decrease, and the risks remain.
4. Invest in Quality Properties: Better-quality houses in prime locations will become more scarce and retain their value over time.
In conclusion, the next phase of the real estate industry will focus on quality and trust, not speed. Off-the-market housing sales mark the beginning of a new era of trust in the market.