虎嗅

Starship is on its way, Starlink is waiting: The intersection of Starship V3 and Starlink V3 projects, and the mismatch in their timelines

原文:星舰在赶,星链在等:星舰V3与星链V3的工程交汇及其节奏错位

Summary of Key Points

Tomorrow (July 17th), SpaceX's 13th test flight of the Starship (the second attempt with the V3 version) will mark the first time that 20 actual Starlink V3 satellites will be carried. This is a critical milestone as both projects converge. The Starlink V3 represents a generational upgrade in satellite technology, featuring increased capacity and lower costs, but it can only be deployed using the Starship V3. However, the Starship itself is still in the trial phase and has not yet successfully delivered satellites into orbit, which is delaying the large-scale deployment of Starlink V3. The success of this test flight will directly determine whether Starlink can achieve gigabit internet speeds, serve aviation and maritime users, and reduce costs. It represents a significant leap from theoretical planning to practical verification.

Detailed Explanation

1. Tomorrow's Test Flight: What Tests Will Be Conducted with the Actual Starlink V3 Satellites?

The 12th test flight of the Starship carried "simulated weights" that only occupied space but did not function. This time, 20 real Starlink V3 satellites will be used. Although these satellites will not reach orbit and will burn up 20 minutes after release, two crucial tests need to be completed:

  • Can the Starship safely deliver the payload? This test will verify the reliability of opening the cargo bay doors and separating the satellites (only simulated versions have been tested before).
  • Can the satellites operate properly? The satellites must deploy their solar panels to generate power and establish laser links for communication with each other, which are essential for their normal functioning. If these tests are successful, Starlink V3 can move on to orbital deployment; otherwise, the design will need to be revised.

2. Why Is the Starship the Only Option for Deploying Starlink V3 Satellites?

The Starlink V3 satellites are quite large: each one weighs over 2 tons and has a wingspan of 60 meters (equivalent to a 20-story building). The Falcon 9 rocket's cargo bay is not capable of accommodating them. The Starship was specifically designed as a "super delivery vehicle" for this purpose:

  • Large Capacity: It can transport up to 60 Starlink V3 satellites at once, with each satellite providing a data capacity of 1024 Gbps. A single launch will thus deliver a total downstream capacity of 61.44 Tbps—20 times more than when Falcon 9 launches V2 Mini satellites.
  • Low Cost: The Starship can be reused (theoretically up to 100 times), significantly reducing the cost per Gbps of data transmission. This is crucial for Starlink to achieve its goal of reducing costs by 90%.

However, the Starship is still in the testing phase. During the 12th flight, the booster experienced an abnormal engine restart, resulting in a hard landing and the failure to deliver satellites into orbit. It's like a delivery vehicle without a license; no matter how good the package is, it can't be delivered.

3. The Leap from 100 Mbps to Gigabit Speeds and Cost Reduction by 90%

The Starlink V3 represents more than just a minor upgrade; it's a complete system change:

  • Speed Increase: Each satellite has a data capacity of 1024 Gbps, more than ten times that of the V2 Mini satellites. With mass deployment, average users will see a significant increase in internet speed (for example, downloading a movie from minutes to seconds).
  • Wider Coverage: Starlink V3 can provide stable service for aviation and maritime users, who previously faced poor signal quality with the V2 Mini version.
  • Cost Reduction: SpaceX claims that the manufacturing cost per Gbps of Starlink V3 satellites has been reduced by 90%. This means that what used to cost $9 to produce 1 Gbps of capacity now costs only $1, which is crucial for Starlink's profitability.

4. The Delay Between the Development of Starship and Starlink V3

Although the satellite technology for Starlink V3 is ready (designed for mass deployment), the Starship is still working on verifying its core capabilities:

  • Starship Immaturity: The Starship is still testing various aspects, such as the return of boosters, spacecraft orbit insertion, and payload release. Each configuration change (e.g., from V2 to V3) requires re-collecting data.
  • High Dependency: Starlink V3 relies entirely on the Starship for deployment. Any delay in the Starship's development will also delay the deployment of Starlink V3 satellites.

It's like having the package ready, but the delivery vehicle needs repairs. Although both are called "V3," their maturity levels differ, leading to a mismatch in development timelines.

5. Additional Challenges Before Full Deployment

Even if the test flight is successful, there are several hurdles that Starlink V3 must overcome before it can be used commercially:

  • Orbital Verification: Future flights will need to ensure that the satellites can stay in orbit and function properly.
  • Mass Deployment: The Starship must be able to deliver 60 satellites at once (which has not yet been achieved).
  • Regulatory Approval: Countries need to approve the frequency bands and network access for Starlink V3 (for example, China has not granted this approval yet).
  • Commercial Adoption: Starlink needs to attract major customers in industries like aviation and maritime, while also reducing the cost of terminals to make them affordable to ordinary users.

Only once all these challenges are overcome can Starlink V3's gigabit speeds and low costs be transformed into real commercial value.

In One Sentence

Tomorrow's test flight is a critical step for Starlink V3 to move from the laboratory to practical use. However, users will not be able to benefit from its gigabit speeds until the Starship is fully tested and regulatory hurdles are cleared. Regardless of the outcome, this flight will provide valuable data to help align the development timelines of both projects.