虎嗅

From "Offers" to "Chinese Restaurants": Why Has the Elite Image Suddenly Lost Its Credibility?

原文:从《Offer》到《中餐厅》,精英人设为什么突然不灵了?

Summary of Key Points

The controversial behavior of Zhang Yaqi in "Chinese Restaurant" (such as forgetting to deliver tableware, shirking responsibilities, and mishandling orders) has sparked widespread discussion online, reflecting two major changes: first, the public's disillusionment with the "elite" persona—people no longer solely admire someone based on their educational background but place more emphasis on practical work skills; second, a shift in workplace emotions—young people are moving from identifying with "successful elites" to empathizing with "ordinary workers," focusing more on teamwork, fairness, and leadership's ability to support their colleagues. The show has become a catalyst for these emotional reactions, reflecting the evolution of workplace expectations across different generations.

Zhang Yaqi's Controversies: What Workplace "Triggers" Did She Hit?

Zhang Yaqi's issues are not isolated mistakes but collectively hit the most frustrating "minefields" in real workplaces:

  • "Promises Without Action": Wang Junkai repeatedly asked her to deliver tableware, but she kept busy with other things, and it was ultimately Wang Junkai who had to do it himself—a classic example of a colleague who talks without acting, causing repeated rework for the team.
  • "Shirking Responsibility": She mistakenly remembered the wrong table number, then blamed Wang Junkai, typical of someone who shifts blame when problems arise.
  • "Unrealistic Promises": She took on a custom cake order without consulting the kitchen, putting pressure on Jiang Yan—a situation similar to some colleagues who take credit without team approval to please leaders or clients.
  • "Busy but Ineffective": Despite appearing energetic, her actions (filling glasses too full, bumping into customers, and missing steps in the process) increased costs and caused delays—netizens called her the "real-life version of the 'Purple Sweet Potato Spirit'" (constantly busy yet increasing the team's workload).

These details resonated with viewers, with one commenting, "She reminds me of that PM who always pretends to be working hard."

The Demise of the Elite Persona: Educational Background Is No Longer a Guarantee

Zhang Yaqi's previous image was that of an elite with a master's degree from Boston University Law School. Her academic credentials and disciplined lifestyle in short videos made her popular. However, the reality shown in "Chinese Restaurant" exposed a gap between her image and her actual abilities:

  • Audiences Are Becoming More Critical: People no longer assume that a prestigious education equals competence; they now focus on whether someone can get tasks done well. For example, one viewer noted, "Only after studying law did I realize her skills weren't much different from those of an average excellent student."
  • Economic Changes Affect Attitudes: With slower economic growth and increased job competition, a high degree is no longer a guarantee of stability. Young people question: If your abilities are similar to those of ordinary people, why should you get more resources through a reality show?
  • Images Must Be Upheld: Only those with proven capabilities, like Guo Wentao (with dual degrees from Peking University and demonstrated intelligence), can continue to benefit from the elite status. Zhang Yaqi's disconnect between image and performance led to backlash.

The Shift in Workplace Emotions: From Aspiring to Empathizing with Workers

The audience's perspective has changed:

  • Past Workplace Dramas: In 2010, shows like "Lurking" focused on how people could climb the corporate ladder, with discussions about how to succeed. In 2015, "Happy Song" admired the success of characters like Andy.
  • Current View in "Chinese Restaurant": Viewers now empathize with ordinary employees, such as Jin Mengjia (who struggles at work) and Jiang Yan (who takes the blame). They idealize leaders who solve problems through example (like filling glasses before serving) and prevent mistakes (by setting up tables properly).
  • Shift in Focus: Young people no longer care about promotions and raises but whether their work is meaningful, whether they get blamed unfairly, and whether leaders will support them. This is reflected in criticisms of corporate jargon in shows like "The Annual Meeting Cannot Stop" and discussions about layoffs in "Ordinary People's Song."

Why "Chinese Restaurant" Became a Trigger for Workplace Emotions?

The show's inherent focus on the workplace, combined with social media dissemination, made it an outlet for these emotions:

  • Relatable Settings: Running a restaurant requires teamwork (ordering, kitchen, service), similar to departmental collaboration in the real workplace. The details (like missing tableware and serving wrong food) are common challenges.
  • Social Media's Impact: Reviews on platforms like Bilibili, engaging edits on Douyin, and analyses on REDnote linked the show's scenarios to real-life work experiences, enhancing empathy.
  • Collective Resonance: Zhang Yaqi's behavior tapped into young people's frustrations with mismatched skills and resources, workplace shirking of responsibility, and ineffective busyness.

Conclusion

The controversy around "Chinese Restaurant" essentially reflects the anxiety of contemporary young workers. The shift from admiring elites to empathizing with ordinary employees, and from focusing on success to questioning competition, is driven by economic and social changes. Zhang Yaqi is just a microcosm of these issues—everyone faces challenges like dealing with unproductive colleagues, seeking good leaders, and ensuring fairness in opportunities and resources. These are the real concerns for people.